Cast
Kasha Fauscett
Sarah
Sam Wickey
Jake
Reed Haymons
Young Samuel
Wesley Juels
Samuel
Connor Falk
Young Amos (as Conner Falk)
Parker Juels
Amos
Brooke Bowman
Young Barb
McAlyn Forbes
Barb
Bella Motter
Young Esther
Allie Taylor
Esther
Mireya Zellner
Young Emma
Madison Schweitz
Emma
Jasmine Fauscett
Young Sarah
Emily Seracuse
Anny
Catherine Bowman
Young Marie
Recommended
6.5
Love Finds You In Sugarcreek
2014
6.7
Violent Saturday
1955
6.2
Love Finds You in Charm
2015
5.8
Come Sunday
2018
6.1
The Shunning
2011
6.1
Holy Lands
2019
7
The Young One
1960
6.1
The Nest
2020
6.3
Rogue Agent
2022
6.2
Gracie
2007
6.3
Preacher's Kid
2010
6.6
Trafficked
2017
6.4
Skin
2009
7.1
Witness
1985
6.3
The River
1984
6.6
Do You Believe?
2015
6.7
Girl in the Box
2016
6.2
God's Not Dead 2
2016
5.9
The Padre
2018
5.9
Winged Creatures
2009
Similar Movies
6.7
Violent Saturday
1955
7
Amish Grace
2010
5.2
Saving Sarah Cain
2007
The Confession Musical
2023
7.9
Wasteland
2019
7.1
Witness
1985
Blinding Light
2024
6.1
The Frisco Kid
1979
7.9
An Amish Sin
2022
6.5
Love Finds You In Sugarcreek
2014
6.7
Expecting Amish
2014
6.2
Love Finds You in Charm
2015
6.1
Plain Truth
2004
5.8
Harvest of Fire
1996
6.1
The Shunning
2011
7.1
Christmas at the Amish Bakery
2023
5.8
An Amish Murder
2013
6
The Reckoning
2015
6.6
Beverly Lewis' The Confession
2013
Brimstone, the Amish Horse
1968